Susie Searches From the director Sophie Kargman The title character begins with Susie (Kiersey Clemons) said that as a child, he always knew how the story would end. In the opening pages of a book, he could immediately deduce the conclusion—an ability he used as a college student to start his own true crime podcast. When Susie isn’t in class, caring for her mother who has MS, or working on her campus job with her rude colleague Jillian (Rachel Sennett) and his eccentric boss Edgar (why marino), she volunteers at the local police station and tries to learn more about solving crimes. When fellow student Jessie (Alex Wolff)—who has some notoriety on campus for his online meditation videos—disappears, Susie pursues the case, which she hopes will eventually close her podcast.
Co-written by Kargman and William de Frank, Search Susie It’s like Jesse’s meditation videos: well-meaning but sometimes awkward in execution. Search Susie A film that sheds light on some surprisingly dark subjects, but underneath a twee sheen that makes it feel distinctly at odds with itself. It’s one thing, as this investigation progresses, we learn that Susie isn’t quite the detective we once thought she was trying to do her best, but that still doesn’t make these tonal shifts less problematic.
Clemons is quite charming in this role, even if these changes affect his performance the most. Especially in the latter part of this story, Susie’s motivations will change from scene to scene regardless of what the narrative needs. At a certain point, Susie’s mother isn’t even part of the equation, despite being a major part of Susie’s motivation. There are also many ideas that Search Susie Hints at the discussion, but doesn’t fully explore it. For example, Susie Searches The first act makes a revelation that changes what we think of this character going forward, and yet, the film doesn’t fully deal with the implications of this choice. The film also seems like it’s barely dipping its toe into discussing ethics in true crime journalism, but somehow realizes it has nothing to say about it and leaves that conversation entirely.